So. You want to start with Smart Home?
I spent a weekend researching about this topic. Here you can find extract with several links that might save you some time.
My goal was very simple. I’ve got Salt lamp with 15W light bulb and I would like to control it from mobile phone.
Before we embark on the journey I recommend to read RFC 1925 at least two points:
- (1) It has to work.
- (8) It is more complicated than you think.
Keep that in mind. Our journey can begin.
Group #1: Devices which do not care about net
The first group that I discovered were devices which has no integration with network.
It is simple and cheap hardware which allows time based control of power socket for the lamp: Solight time switch.
Price: 339 Kč / 12 EUR
Solight does not support remote control.
Similar solution, but with remote control is RSL2. You can control several sockets with one remote control. The neat feature of this solution is ability to dim the light.
Price: 459 Kč / 17 EUR
The downside for this and several other sockets described in the article is that they’re targeted at German/Western market and you need to buy reduction to Czech/Slovak power plug.
Price: 71 Kč / 3 EUR
Then I found socket with interesting design which has support for remote control and you can turn it on just by pressing button: PowerCube. The button does not require any extra batteries. That’s very useful feature. Just some people on the internet complained that sometimes thay had to push the button twice. The button can be paired with more PowerCubes or more buttons can be paired one PowerCube.
Price: 659 Kč / 24 EUR
Group #2: Devices which do not care about cloud
I found this group at the end of my search.
Ubiquiti mFi mPower
Wow! mFi mPower! It has everything, because it is running on Linux. Wifi and even SSH interface. Android app or any script can interact with the device. The price is very reasonable.
Unfortunately the software development for this platform was placed on hold early this year. That is not good. Just two days ago there was another huge DDOS attack at Dyn which knocked out even GitHub. I’m not saying that it was caused by mFi devices. I just want to stress out that security patches are very important for smart devices.
Price: 1020 Kč / 42 EUR
BeeWi Bluetooth Smart Plug
Another device which is able to operate without cloud is BeeWi socket which communicates via Bluetooth with mobile phone. It is also possible to connect BeeWi to cloud, which requires special gateway from the same vendor.
Price: 1099 Kč / 45 EUR
Group #3: Devices addicted to cloud
There is large group of devices which operates on WiFi, but these devices are dependent on cloud. The dependency is not necessary bad thing, but you should be aware of it. It might very easy happen that the cloud is not accessible and you won’t be able to control the devices.
Isn’t it strange that with every flip of switch you need to generate some command and operation on remote server in the cloud?
The best match for the solution controlled via WiFi seems to be TP-LINK HS110. Android app has very high reviews. Just the iPad version is missing, so you have to use iPhone.
Price: 1079 Kč / 44 EUR
D-Link DSP-W215 SmartPlug
I found very alarming reviews of D-Link DSP-W215. Users were complaining that the device violates Czech electrical standards.
Price: 1399 Kč / 58 EUR
Belkin – WeMo Insight Switch
WeMo solutions seems to be popular, but I found large number of very negative reviews of control app for Android. It reminds me on old bloated Samsung Kies. This solutions works via WiFi and requires connection to the cloud.
Price: 1561 Kč / 65 EUR
Group #4: Devices which talks together
This is the most complex group. These devices implements protocols like Z-Wave or Zigbee which does not operate with the same protocols as BlueTooth or WiFi. It means that you often need a server which controls behavior of devices and which is able to relay instructions from your mobile app to the protocol implemented by devices.
FIBARO – Wall Plug
FIBARO has simply great design, neat functions. Little bit more expensive, but where is the catch?
Price: 1799 Kč / 74 EUR
FIBARO – Home Center 2
Here is the catch. You need FIBARO Home Center 2 to be able to communicate with FIBARO Wall Plug. The device allows you to control and gather report from your smart home network. The only problem is that the price is little bit higher than you would expect.
Price: 16499 Kč / 687 EUR
There is also FIBARO Home Center Lite which has little bit simple HW configuration and it is about half the prices of Home Center 2.
Aeon Labs Z-WAVE USB Z-STICK GEN5
It is possible to use your own server instead of FIBARO Home Center, but you’ll need USB dongle like Aeon Z-Wave which is able to communicate via Z-Wave protocol.
Price: 1320 Kč / 55 EUR
Once you’ve got USB dongle you can set up your own home automation server like OpenHAB. Just unzip the file, copy configuration. Start the Java server and connect to web interface. Then you can use application on your mobile phone to control your home network. OpenHAB is very flexible and authors received Duke’s choice award in 2013.
It is also possible to connect devices described in group “Addicted to cloud” and control these devices just from your own server. There are several other open source home automation systems. You can find the list at OpenSource.com.
Price: 0 Kč / 0 EUR
Zigbee is similar protocol to Z-Wave. It operates in 2.4 Ghz like WiFi or BlueTooth. You need also separate dongle to talk to this network of devices. Zigbee has been adopted also by Samsung Smartthings.
There are also other protocols, but the idea is always the same. You need dongle or special bridge to talk to your network of devices. These devices are often able to talk with each other.
As you can see the market is quite diverse and complex. We started with very simple solutions and gradually continued to very complex server controlled solutions. It is often confusing for beginners to spot difference between socket using WiFi or Z-Wave. I hope that this article shed some light to the topic.
Thank you for reading. If you see that something in article is not correct or misleading, let me know. I’ll be happy to fix it.
And what was my decision after weekend analysis of Smart Home? I will buy just a simple flash light and I will turn the switch manually 😉